Selection policies are documents that state the criteria and requirements for programme and competition selection. Every sport is different, but most will have these documents for selection to World Class programmes, and all other major competitions, including the Olympic and Paralympic Games.
It is your responsibility to make sure you are clear about the designated selection events and performance standards you are aiming to achieve.
Having a comprehensive understanding of the selection policy and criteria will provide you with an understanding of performance expectations and targets.
• The aims/objectives of the policy; and composition of selection panel
• The performance/selection criteria and the relevant data that is being looked at
• Differing ‘rounds’ of selection and how they will be governed
• Illness/injury exemptions, considerations and how they will be managed (disclosure is key)
• The number of individuals being selected per event/programme
• How and when the information will be communicated
• Unique elements to the sport
• Sports often engage with us on an advisory capacity while writing their selection policies
• We can deliver workshops which break down selection policies for athletes
• Athletes can engage with us if they want our help clarifying, or raising concerns over elements of a selection policy (in advance of the selection date)
• We often sit as independent observers within selection panels
• Within this role, it is our responsibility to ensure that the selection policy is followed, and that conversations do not deviate away from the selection policy criteria
Programme selection usually happens once a year, the timing of this can vary between sports. Being selected onto the WCP usually means you will receive financial support from UK Sport in the form of an Athlete Performance Award and have access to UKSI services – this again can vary between sports.
De-selection from programme can be due to many factors including; injury, conduct, performance related and funding. The de-selection process varies from sport to sport and is outlined in your selection policy.
Competition selection can happen at various points in the year depending on each sports’ competition calendar. Competition selection policies are unique to each sport and may change year on year.
An appeals process is a mechanism to challenge the outcome of a selection meeting in which you believe there has been a departure from the process in the selection policy.
An appeals process is not an opportunity to raise concerns around the contents of a selection policy or challenge a decision simply because you do not agree with the outcome. Nor is it an opportunity to raise concerns that should have been shared throughout the season.
An athlete can sometimes request redacted notes/minutes from the selection meeting. If available, this is advisable as it may inform the decision. NGBs are not legally required to comply.
The grounds to appeal a deselection or non-selection can be found in your NGB selection policy. They usually fall under four statements:
• There had been a failure to follow process outlined un the selection policy
• The selection panel, or any member of it involved in making the selection decision, has shown actual bias or may have a conflict of interest when making the decision.
• The selection panel reached a decision based on an error of fact.
• The decision is unreasonable and one that no reasonable decision maker could have reached.
Procedure - Appeals procedures should either be laid out within a selection document, or in a separate appeals document. All of these documents should be readily available to all athletes.
Timelines – timelines for appeals vary between sports. It is a critical that an athlete knows the timeline prior to communication of decision.
Cost – it is up to NGBs whether they charge a fee for the submission of an appeal. The cost is typically refunded if the appeal is successful.
• We will provide a safe space for an athlete to discuss their selection decision
• Where time permits, we can facilitate a meeting between the athlete and their sport to support their understanding of the decision
• To the best of our knowledge, we will provide advice on their grounds of appeal – NB, we are completely transparent with athletes, and if we do not believe they have grounds for appeal, we make this clear.
• The allocated athlete support manager will support them through the appeals process should they choose to submit an appeal.
• If appropriate, the BEAA can refer the athlete to its partner ‘Sports Resolutions UK’ for pro bono legal support on their behalf.
Outcomes of an appeals process
Winning an appeal does not mean overturning decision. The selection panel will consider the findings of the appeals panel, but selection cannot be guaranteed. Once the appeals process has been made once it cannot be made again. If you need further advice on selections & appeals, the BEAA offers a workshop to athletes.